OUR HISTORY.
A FAMILY LEGACY. GENERATIONS IN THE MAKING.
More than a gun store. More than seven decades of stories.
BUILT BY A MAN WHO
NEVER STOPPED BUILDING.
The story of Butter-nut Sport Shop begins on the Northside of Syracuse, New York, in the late 1950s, with a man named William “Wild Bill” Greene.
Long before Butter-nut became a familiar name among Central New York's firearms enthusiasts, Bill Greene Sr. was an entrepreneur with a passion for automobiles, motorcycles, firearms, and just about anything mechanical.
His first business was an automobile dealership on Wolf Street in Syracuse. But Bill's interests extended well beyond cars, and it wasn't long before he began shifting his attention toward firearms, hunting equipment, and gunsmithing.
That decision would eventually lead to the creation of a business that would outlive its founder and become a lasting part of his family's legacy.
FROM WOLF STREET TO BUTTERNUT STREET.
As Bill's firearms business grew, he relocated to a small, two-story building on Butternut Street in Syracuse. There, he established the Butternut Sport Shop.
The building served as both his home and his business, allowing him to dedicate his time to growing the shop while continuing to operate his automobile dealership on Wolf Street.
For several years, Bill built his reputation through his knowledge of firearms, mechanical expertise, and willingness to tackle projects that other shops might turn away.
Eventually, the business outgrew its modest surroundings. Bill needed more room, and he found it in a rather unlikely place.
A NEW HOME ON LODI STREET.
In 1970, Bill opened the doors of the Butter-nut Sport Shop at 1103 Lodi Street in Syracuse.
The building had once operated as an ice factory, but Bill saw something more. Over the years, he personally renovated, expanded, and transformed the property into the business he envisioned.
What emerged was far more than a traditional sporting goods store. Butter-nut became a place where customers could purchase firearms and ammunition, have their guns repaired, and benefit from Bill's extensive mechanical knowledge.
His gunsmithing experience, developed during his time working in an armory with the United States Marine Corps, made the shop one of the few Central New York establishments offering gunsmithing services on-site.
And firearms weren't the only things coming through the doors. Motorcycles, sports cars, and mechanical projects were all part of Bill's world. If something had an engine, moving parts, or a problem that needed solving, chances were Bill wanted to get his hands on it.
A CENTRAL NEW YORK INSTITUTION.
From 1970 through the mid-1980s, Butter-nut Sport Shop grew into one of Central New York's leading firearms retailers. During its busiest years, the store sold thousands of firearms annually.
Customers came for the selection, but they also came for the experience and knowledge behind the counter. Bill's reputation as a gunsmith and businessman helped establish Butter-nut as a destination for generations of hunters, shooters, collectors, and firearm enthusiasts.
But Bill was never a man content with operating just one business. Over time, his entrepreneurial interests expanded into a full used-car dealership, a farm in Port Byron, and the buying and selling of heavy equipment.
With so many ventures demanding his attention, Butter-nut eventually reduced its operating schedule to just two days a week. That schedule continued for many years. Even as the store's hours became limited, Butter-nut remained part of the Central New York firearms community.
A LEGACY WE COULDN'T LET END.
April 29, 2020. It was one of the hardest days in Butter-nut Sport Shop's history.
William “Wild Bill” Greene passed away at the age of 87, just one month shy of his 88th birthday.
For decades, Bill had been the driving force behind Butter-nut. He was its founder, its gunsmith, its personality, and the man whose determination had built the business from the ground up.
His passing left his family with an enormous loss—and an equally enormous decision. What would become of Grandpa's gun store?
WE WEREN'T GOING TO LET HIS LIFE'S WORK DISAPPEAR.
With the COVID-19 pandemic bringing much of the world to a standstill, reopening a business was anything but easy. Nevertheless, our family established Butter-nut Sport Shop Inc. and prepared to carry the business into its next chapter.
As soon as New York State's reopening phases permitted, we welcomed customers back through the doors. The store returned to regular operations, once again offering firearms, ammunition, shooting supplies, gunsmithing, and repairs.
It wasn't the same without Grandpa behind the counter. It never would be. But his legacy was alive.
VISIT WILD BILL'S CORNERA NEW CHAPTER IN MINOA.
After more than five decades at 1103 Lodi Street, Butter-nut Sport Shop began another chapter in its history. In 2023, we relocated from Syracuse to 249 North Main Street in Minoa, New York.
The move marked the end of an era. For generations, the Lodi Street building had been synonymous with Butter-nut Sport Shop. Its walls held decades of memories, countless conversations, and the hard work of the man who had made it all possible.
Leaving that building meant saying goodbye to a place that had been part of our family's history for more than fifty years. But it didn't mean leaving that history behind.
The move to Minoa gave Butter-nut a new home while allowing us to continue the traditions established by Wild Bill.
THE BUILDING CHANGED. THE ADDRESS CHANGED.
THE FAMILY BEHIND THE COUNTER REMAINED.
STILL GRANDPA'S GUN STORE.
Today, Butter-nut Sport Shop continues to operate as a family-owned sporting goods and firearms business in Minoa, New York.
We carry new and used firearms, ammunition, shooting accessories, fishing equipment, and more, while continuing the gunsmithing tradition that helped make Butter-nut what it is.
We've made changes over the years, and we'll continue making them as the business grows. But there are some things we never intend to change.
We believe in knowing our customers, sharing what we've learned, and treating people like more than another sale. We believe that experience matters. We believe that family businesses still have a place in this world.
And we believe that the best way to honor the generations who came before us is to make sure there's something worth passing down to the generations who come after.
Thank you for being part of our family's story. Whether you've been shopping with us for decades or you're planning your first visit, we look forward to welcoming you.